Charity Fund Relief Inflated Boys Introduce Procedural Justice

When 13-year-old Shandong boy Du Chuanwang was working in a garage, he was injured by an inmate with an air pump. After his experience was revealed by the media, the Angel Mothers Fund, a Beijing-based private charity organization, promptly initiated public fundraising for him and received him from Shandong’s Bayi Children’s Hospital in Shandong for treatment.

The beginning of this charity story is no different. But a few days later, the charity act of the Angel Mothers Fund was not fully embraced by flowers, but tortured by public magnifiers.

The Angel Mother Fund won the China Charity Award twice for its charity award. With doubts, the Angel Mother’s Fund’s public welfare trip shrouded in doubt.

Public welfare assistance drew controversy

In the description of the media and the Internet, Du Chuanwang said that “the scrotum is as big as a small watermelon”, her stomach “highly bulges like a pregnant woman”, and her “organisms are all squeezed together” and her organs are seriously damaged. People saw this description and pictures on Weibo, and some people "difficultly dared to open the picture after reading the text." Many people called for severe punishment of the perpetrators.

The Angel Mothers Foundation has been in touch with this matter since July 11.

At 16:17 on the same day, a dialogue was transmitted on the microblog of the Angel Mother Fund. Someone asked: "Can you help him (Du Chuan-wang)?" Mother Angel replied: "Indignant! The murderer must punish! Where is the child? Please contact us!"

The Angel Mother Fund (hereinafter referred to as "Angel Mom") is a special fund under the China Youth Children's Charity Relief Fund. Its website says that Angel Mother is a volunteer team, members and most of the donors are caring and well-educated. Background and all aspects of the mother.

From the decision to rescue Chuan Wang, Angel Mother’s official Weibo content has not said anything else. In 1 hour on July 11th and around 1700, the mother of Angels released two messages through Weibo: They are consulting Beijing experts and are organizing a rescue mission.

At 18:15, the mother of Angels said that she had contacted the local hospital and was in contact with the children's family to prepare to transfer the child to Beijing.

At 19:03, Angel Mother said that her father was unable to raise money to come to Beijing. He estimated that the budget for ambulances and treatment would be 100,000 yuan and he appealed for donations. The donation link for the public offering platform is attached below.

From this moment onwards, "different voices" began to appear, and some felt "wrong."

Within 24 hours of Angel Mother’s decision to rescue and initiate the public offer, various questions have come to light and quickly spread –

Why did you choose an "unknown hospital"? Is there an unspoken "dark screen" between the fund and the hospital? Is it really a matter of collecting money?

On July 12th, Angel Mother released Weibo and responded to four questions: the relationship between Angel Mother and Childhood Society, the source of funds, the qualifications of Bayi Children's Hospital and the current donation status, and called for an end to donations.

However, the "different voices" have not disappeared and have become increasingly fierce.

At 13:21 on July 13th, a netizen named “Sasha Gangsha” stated that “Du Chuanwang’s family had never seen a child since yesterday afternoon and had not seen anyone at the Foundation. Whatever he did, he did not dare to provoke foundations, did not dare to transfer hospitals, and feared not to pay medical fees, but had to sit in the door of the hospital. The bank account of Du Chuanwang’s father, which was announced at the beginning, was not in the hands of his family, but the foundation did... ”

This information, which later proved to be false, was transmitted tens of thousands of times.

At this point, both sounds began to collide violently. Deng Fei, a free luncheon sponsor of the non-governmental charity organization, and the “Beijing cook”, a netizen who also engages in public charity, stand on the side of Angel Mother.

At 17 o'clock on July 13th, Angel Mother responded to questions that people questioned in the form of online interviews.

On July 14th, the mother of the angels announced the convening of the Chuan Wang Disease Conference and answered the questions face to face.

The mother of Angels made this announcement at 13:15. At the press conference at 16:00, they found that all media reporters from all over the country had arrived, and some had issued "different voices."

Mother Angel first published some information and then entered the questioning session. The first person to stand up and ask questions is a public person. His questions point to hospital qualifications and salvage procedures.

Both sides evolved from question and answer to confrontation. Without a microphone, the volume on both sides became higher and higher.

Is it too fast to decide

Why did the mother of the angels explain several times and the suspicious cloud did not disappear, but it intensified? Why can't we help the public to doubt the justice of their motives?

At the press conference, someone asked that the investigation of Du Chuanwang's condition did not include an investigation by the mother of the angel. She decided quickly based on media and Weibo reports, and was not responsible for the children and donors.

Angel Mother said, "We believe in the media. We also believe in local hospitals."

Netizen "Beijing cook" backed angel mother. “I have the same attitude with them in the prosperous things.” In the past few days, whenever someone questioned the mother’s exaggeration and accused them of controlling bank cards and preventing family members from seeing children, “Beijing cooks” Will stand up and reply.

He thinks that the mother of angel is very embarrassed. "If someone finds them, they are willing to take over. What's wrong with this?" The verification process is as impeccable as the public thinks, "God's point of view," and it is not important. The important thing is that "first and foremost". . "This is like a fire. Is it quick to rescue after hearing the fire? Or is it going to go? After the process has been there, the fire will burn everything down."

However, public figures only allowed Dodge to disagree with these views. He told the China Youth Daily reporter that he was very supportive of the charitable organization's ability to do everything in its power to save children quickly. However, “swift rescue” does not mean “quick public offering”. Because of the donations from a pen fundraiser, it is difficult to return one by one as soon as it is converged, so charities should verify the basic situation before making a donation.

It was only then that Dodge believed that if a non-profit organization could not independently investigate and evaluate the recipients, its project would be in danger at the very beginning. The ensuing question is: "If Angel Mother does not have a field survey and has not seen Du Chuan Wang himself, why not first use the existing funds of the 'Angel Mom Foundation' to act first, and then wait until after the treatment plan and the cost estimate have come out. Initiating social donations can also avoid current social challenges."

At the conference site, this issue was raised, but it was not answered affirmatively and was overwhelmed by the intense dialogue.

Today, the mother of Angel Mother's staff told reporters of the China Youth Daily. At that time, the angel mother team was in Beijing, but everyone communicated with the local doctor several times by telephone. Shen Li himself also obtained a picture of the child's face through a doctor.

In addition, they had published information through the QQ group and recruited a volunteer called “March” to go to the hospital to view the scene.

Shen Li said that she did not communicate with the parents of the children and was communicated by Xu Man, another staff member of Angel Mother. "March" is not her contact, I do not know is a man or a woman.

Xu Man told this reporter that in her impression, the time to contact the Shandong Xiajin People's Hospital at the beginning of Du Chuanwang's consultation should be around 5 pm. “Then they passed the hospital's family's phone and communicated several times before and after.”

According to Xu Man, the volunteers who participated in the verification and verification were not directly connected with her, but they were linked at the first level and gradually worked down.

How is "good treatment?"

Why Bayi Children's Hospital instead of Peking Union Medical College Hospital or even 301 Hospital? Some skeptical people firmly believe that this is a major doubt for Angel Mother and Bayi Children's Hospital's “transmission of interests”.

This logic seems unreasonable to the "Beijing chef". “A public hospital must be a good resource, a suitable and affordable place for children?” He believes that it is too unfair to judge the hospital’s qualifications with fame.

"Beijing cook" has also initiated some charity activities. He told reporters that social resources such as his “grassroots” charity can't balance everything. More often than not, the incident has entered the dilemma little by little with the process and the only option at that time. “People may ask why you chose this way. In fact, I have no choice but to make such a choice. However, it is painful to tell.”

Does the mother of Angels also face the pain of "can't choose"? After long-term trade-offs, does it choose to cooperate with Bayi Children's Hospital for a long time?

At the scene of the disease briefing, the reporter used this to ask the angel mother responsible person, and then repeatedly asked its responsible person, but the angel mother did not disclose the details. The explanation they gave was: Although there are many high-quality medical resources in Beijing, it is difficult to see a doctor. I hope that the reporter can understand it.

For the children who affect the public's love, the mother's every move may be questioned. Some people asked why the children did not live in the ICU (intensive care unit) in Shandong, and they entered the ICU in Beijing. After the child was transferred from the ICU to the general ward, some people questioned how the condition was, how serious it was, but not serious. The hospital has arranged for 6 nurses to take care of the children. Some people think that how to take care of a child will require 6 professionals?

In fact, answering such doubts requires an impartial third-party assessment agency. For example, when a child needs assistance, experts from third-party expert committees provide opinions and suggestions. “In theory, if you are seriously ill, you should send it to the Hospital for Concordia Hospital. The disease is not very serious and you can send it to a community hospital. This is all done by experts. Decide."

"Of course this is right, it is also the standard equipment for modern public welfare." Deng Fei, the promoter of free lunch, said that at the same time, he also said that the civil public welfare projects that have just developed in the cracks need time to establish a variety of systems, even if the country is old. The organization is not perfect. How to equitably select experts, how to obtain expert advice, legitimacy of the action, and process mechanisms, etc., need to be resolved, but no one has yet resolved it.

At noon today, Ms. Shen Li gave this reporter an important message: The Angel Mothers Fund has its own expert database, which includes about 670 medical experts' advisory committees. Each type of department has relevant experts. Why do Du Chuanwang go to Bayi Children's Hospital? Because of Angel Mother's help children, gastroenterology and pediatric surgery were treated at Bayi Children's Hospital. At the beginning, Du Chuanwang’s illness was described as “a lot of holes in the intestines,” so the mother of the angels consulted the Children’s Hospital. .

Some people on the Internet questioned the cooperation between Angel Mother and Bayi Children's Hospital. Shen Li said that they have also cooperated with the Capital Institute of Children's Studies, such as the rescue of an anal child Xu Zibao several years ago.

Shen Li said that for Du Chuanwang's current treatment and guardianship work, the mother of Angels is "to hand over the medical part to the hospital. How the hospital arranges for medical treatment is determined by the hospital. The mother of the angel does not have such great power."

Do you need procedural justice

The Mei Meimei incident has hurt people's enthusiasm for the government-run charity. In recent years, the rapidly emerging grassroots public charity has provided a new channel for people's love.

However, the development of grassroots public welfare is also accompanied by endless questions from the society. At the beginning of the establishment of free lunch, some people questioned why the free lunch program can provide air tickets. "Is the airline ticket money from the free lunch fund? Must we fly? Isn't it the same thing to take the train?"

Deng Fei told reporters that at the beginning they also continued to explain to the public that "certain expenditures were for enhancing efficiency" and then later, he rarely explained again. Because, "You took a plane. Some people think that you should take a train. Some people may think that the train should not be in a sleeper. A hard seat is enough."

“According to this logic, everyone can ask you a thousand questions. Then how do we work?” Deng Fei said that the media should guide everyone to learn professionally and effectively. .

He wrote on Weibo, someone asked, "You are not an angel mother. Why did you insist on defending them and not ignoring free lunches?" "Because I am a friend of the Angel Mother team, I trust this group of 'mothers' who don't know how to express themselves. I feel that fairness and integrity are the bottom line of people, the cornerstone of society, and that protecting a person from being wronged is a matter of rated public interest. Questions or rumors are also helping this team."

On the other side, people who insist on procedural justice are still insisting.

A netizen living in Wuhan told this reporter that she had observed too many "crazy rescue" operations. In the rescue, the public welfare person said that "love children even more than children's parents," and even dressed as a child's mother rushed into the hospital to take the child, if the parents do not agree with the treatment plan, the public to claim that the child's parents are foolish. Some non-profit organizations abducted the fate of their children with moral morale and abducted the public’s love.

After experiencing such incidents, she is particularly sensitive to the procedural barriers of public welfare organizations.

In a larger sense, Deng Fei regards this skepticism as "great training."

“Public organizations raise donations and accept that donors entrust them to implement a public welfare project. It must be open and transparent throughout the entire process, learn to accept rigorous inquiry and independent audit. I know that there must be conflict among them, but we are engaged in a great civic self. Training.” Deng Fei wrote.

Next:Installation, use and regulation of marine diesel generator sets
Previous:Two elderly doctors suddenly broke out after suffering a sudden heart attack